…because this could happen:
Category: Programming
Getting my (rubber) ducks in a row
In programming, there’s a term called rubber duck debugging. It’s a problem-solving technique where you describe the problem you’re facing in as simple a way as possible to an inanimate object, such as a rubber duck.
It’s turned out to be a good way to solve many programming problems. When you describe how something should work and then look at the system and see how it isn’t working, it often becomes easy to spot where the issue is.
You could perform the exact same thing with a person — in fact, it’s one of the things that pair programmers are supposed to do — but when another person isn’t available, a rubber duck can come in pretty handy. So I’ve started a collection.
The newest addition is the Einstein duck, located below the big monitor on the left. I supposed I could’ve ordered it from Amazon, but I bought it at the gift shop the History of Science Museum when I visited Oxford last month.
See also…
- Wikipedia’s Rubber Duck Debugging entry
- MakeUseOf.com: What is Rubber Duck Debugging?
- Thoughtful Code: Rubber Duck Debugging: The Psychology of How it Works

The linked list exercises continue! In case you missed them, be sure to check out part 1 and part 2 of this linked list series before moving forward…
Adding an item to the start of a linked list
In this article, the first new feature we’ll implement is the ability to add new items to the start of the list. It’s similar to adding an item to the end of a list, which is why I reviewed it above.
The diagram below shows the first two nodes of a linked list. Recall that a linked list’s head points to its first node and that every node points to the next one:
Here’s how you add a new node to the start of the list. The new node becomes the first node, and the former first node becomes the second node:
Here are the steps:
- Create a new node. In our implementation, newly-created nodes have a next property that points to
null,nil, orNoneby default. - If the list is empty (i.e. head points to
null,nil, orNone), adding it to the list is the same thing as adding it to the start of the list. Pointheadto the new node and you’re done. - If the list is not empty, you need to do just a little more work.
- Point the new node’s
nextproperty tohead. This makes the current first node the one that comes after the new node. - Point
headat the new node. This makes the new node the first one in the list.
- Point the new node’s
Here’s how I implemented this in Python…
# Python
def add_first(self, value):
new_node = Node(value)
# If the list is empty,
# point `head` to the newly-added node
# and exit.
if self.head is None:
self.head = new_node
return
# If the list isn’t empty,
# make the current first node the second node
# and make the new node the first node.
new_node.next = self.head
self.head = new_node
…and here’s my JavaScript implementation:
# JavaScript
addFirst(value) {
let newNode = new Node(value)
// If the list is empty,
// point `head` to the newly-added node
// and exit.
if (this.head === null) {
this.head = newNode
return
}
// If the list isn’t empty,
// make the current first node the second node
// and make the new node the first node.
newNode = this.head
this.head = newNode
}
Inserting a new item at a specified position in the list
So far, we’ve implemented methods to:
- Add a new item to the start of the list, and
- Add a new item to the end of the list.
Let’s do something a little more complicated: adding a new item at a specified position in the list. The position is specified using a number, where 0 denotes the first position in the list.
Here’s how you add a new node at a specified position in the list.
Here are the steps:
- The function has two parameters:
index: The index where a new node should be inserted into the list, with0denoting the first item.value: The value that should be stored in the new node.
- Create a new node,
new_node, and putvalueinto it. - Use a variable,
current_index, to keep track of the index of the node we’re currently looking at as we traverse the list. It should initially be set to0. - Use another variable,
current_node, which will hold a reference to the node we’re currently looking at. It should initially be set tohead, which means that we’ll start at the first item in the list. - Repeat the following as long as
current_nodeis not referencingnull,nil, orNone:- We’re looking for the node in the position immediately before the position where we want to insert the new node. If
current_indexis one less thanindex:- Point the new node at the current node’s next node.
- Point the current node at the new node.
- Return
true, meaning that we successfully inserted a new item into the list
- If we’re here, it means that we haven’t yet reached the node immediately before the insertion point. Move to the next node and increment
current_index.
- We’re looking for the node in the position immediately before the position where we want to insert the new node. If
- If we’re here, it means that we’ve gone past the last item in the list.
Returnfalse, meaning we didn’t insert a new item into the list.
Here’s how I implemented this in Python…
# Python
def insert_element_at(self, index, value):
new_node = Node(value)
current_index = 0
current_node = self.head
# Traverse the list, keeping count of
# the nodes that you visit,
# until you’ve reached the specified node.
while current_node:
if current_index == index - 1:
# We’re at the node before the insertion point!
# Make the new node point to the next node
# and the current node point to the new node.
new_node.next = current_node.next
current_node.next = new_node
return True
# We’re not there yet...
current_node = current_node.next
current_index += 1
# If you’re here, the given index is larger
# than the number of elements in the list.
return False
…and here’s my JavaScript implementation:
// JavaScript
insertElementAt(index, value) {
let newNode = new Node(value)
let currentIndex = 0
let currentNode = this.head
// Traverse the list, keeping count of
// the nodes that you visit,
// until you’ve reached the specified node.
while (currentNode) {
if (currentIndex === index - 1) {
// We’re at the node before the insertion point!
// Make the new node point to the next node
// and the current node point to the new node.
newNode.next = currentNode.next
currentNode.next = newNode
return true
}
// We’re not there yet...
currentNode = currentNode.next
currentIndex++
}
// If you’re here, the given index is larger
// than the number of elements in the list.
return false
}
Deleting an item from a specified position in the list
Now that we can add a new item at a specified position in the list, let’s implement its opposite: deleting an item from a specified position in the list. Once again, the position is specified using a number, where 0 denotes the first position in the list.
Here’s how you delete a new node from a specified position in the list:
Here are the steps:
- The function has a single parameter,
index: the index of the node to be deleted, with0denoting the first item in the list. - Use a variable,
current_index, to keep track of the index of the node we’re currently looking at as we traverse the list. It should initially be set to0. - Use another variable,
current_node, which will hold a reference to the node we’re currently looking at. It should initially be set tohead, which means that we’ll start at the first item in the list. - Repeat the following as long as
current_nodeis not referencingnull,nil, orNone:- We’re looking for the node in the position immediately before the position of the node we want to delete. If
current_indexis one less thanindex:- Point the current node to the next node’s next node, which removes the next node from the list.
- Set both the next node’s
dataandnextproperties tonull,nil, orNone. At this point, this node is no longer in the list and is an “island” — no object points to it, and it doesn’t point to any objects. It will eventually be garbage collected. - Return
true, meaning that we successfully deleted the item from the list
- If we’re here, it means that we haven’t yet reached the node immediately before the deletion point. Move to the next node and increment
current_index.
- We’re looking for the node in the position immediately before the position of the node we want to delete. If
- If we’re here, it means that we’ve gone past the last item in the list.
Returnfalse, meaning we didn’t delete the item from the list.
Here’s how I implemented this in Python…
# Python
def delete_element_at(self, index):
current_index = 0
current_node = self.head
# Traverse the list, keeping count of
# the nodes that you visit,
# until you’ve reached the specified node.
while current_node:
if current_index == index - 1:
# We’re at the node before the node to be deleted!
# Make the current node point to the next node’s next node
# and set the next node’s `data` and `next` properties
# to `None`.
delete_node = current_node.next
current_node.next = delete_node.next
delete_node.data = None
delete_node.next = None
return True
# We’re not there yet...
current_node = current_node.next
current_index += 1
# If you’re here, the given index is larger
# than the number of elements in the list.
return False
…and here’s my JavaScript implementation:
// JavaScript
deleteElementAt(index) {
let currentIndex = 0
let currentNode = this.head
// Traverse the list, keeping count of
// the nodes that you visit,
// until you’ve reached the specified node.
while (currentNode) {
if (currentIndex === index - 1) {
// We’re at the node before the node to be deleted!
// Make the current node point to the next node’s next node
// and set the next node’s `data` and `next` properties
// to `null`.
const deleteNode = currentNode.next
currentNode.next = deleteNode.next
deleteNode.data = null
deleteNode.next = null
return true
}
// We’re not there yet...
currentNode = currentNode.next
currentIndex++
}
// If you’re here, the given index is larger
// than the number of elements in the list.
return false
}
The classes so far
Let’s take a look at the complete Node and LinkedList classes so far, in both Python and JavaScript.
Python
# Python
class Node:
def __init__(self, data):
self.data = data
self.next = None
def __str__(self):
return f"{self.data}"
class LinkedList:
def __init__(self):
self.head = None
def __str__(self):
if self.head is None:
return('Empty list.')
result = ""
current_node = self.head
while current_node:
result += f'{current_node}\n'
current_node = current_node.next
return result.strip()
def add_last(self, value):
new_node = Node(value)
# If the list is empty,
# point `head` to the newly-added node
# and exit.
if self.head is None:
self.head = new_node
return
# If the list isn’t empty,
# traverse the list by going to each node’s
# `next` node until there isn’t a `next` node...
current_node = self.head
while current_node.next:
current_node = current_node.next
# If you’re here, `current_node` is
# the last node in the list.
# Point `current_node` at
# the newly-added node.
current_node.next = new_node
def __len__(self):
count = 0
current_node = self.head
# Traverse the list, keeping count of
# the nodes that you visit,
# until you’ve gone past the last node.
while current_node:
current_node = current_node.next
count += 1
return count
def get_element_at(self, index):
current_index = 0
current_node = self.head
# Traverse the list, keeping count of
# the nodes that you visit,
# until you’ve reached the specified node.
while current_node:
if current_index == index:
# We’re at the node at the given index!
return current_node.data
# We’re not there yet...
current_node = current_node.next
current_index += 1
# If you’re here, the given index is larger
# than the number of elements in the list.
return None
def set_element_at(self, index, value):
current_index = 0
current_node = self.head
# Traverse the list, keeping count of
# the nodes that you visit,
# until you’ve reached the specified node.
while current_node:
if current_index == index:
# We’re at the node at the given index!
current_node.data = value
return True
# We’re not there yet...
current_node = current_node.next
current_index += 1
# If you’re here, the given index is larger
# than the number of elements in the list.
return False
def add_first(self, value):
new_node = Node(value)
# If the list is empty,
# point `head` to the newly-added node
# and exit.
if self.head is None:
self.head = new_node
return
# If the list isn’t empty,
# make the current first node the second node
# and make the new node the first node.
new_node.next = self.head
self.head = new_node
def insert_element_at(self, index, value):
new_node = Node(value)
current_index = 0
current_node = self.head
# Traverse the list, keeping count of
# the nodes that you visit,
# until you’ve reached the specified node.
while current_node:
if current_index == index - 1:
# We’re at the node before the insertion point!
# Make the new node point to the next node
# and the current node point to the new node.
new_node.next = current_node.next
current_node.next = new_node
return True
# We’re not there yet...
current_node = current_node.next
current_index += 1
# If you’re here, the given index is larger
# than the number of elements in the list.
return False
def delete_element_at(self, index):
current_index = 0
current_node = self.head
# Traverse the list, keeping count of
# the nodes that you visit,
# until you’ve reached the specified node.
while current_node:
if current_index == index - 1:
# We’re at the node before the node to be deleted!
# Make the current node point to the next node’s next node
# and set the next node’s `data` and `next` properties
# to `None`.
delete_node = current_node.next
current_node.next = delete_node.next
delete_node.data = None
delete_node.next = None
return True
# We’re not there yet...
current_node = current_node.next
current_index += 1
# If you’re here, the given index is larger
# than the number of elements in the list.
return False
JavaScript
// JavaScript
class Node {
constructor(data) {
this.data = data
this.next = null
}
toString() {
return this.data.toString()
}
}
class LinkedList {
constructor() {
this.head = null
}
toString() {
if (!this.head) {
return('Empty list.')
}
let output = ""
let currentNode = this.head
while (currentNode) {
output += `${currentNode.data.toString()}\n`
currentNode = currentNode.next
}
return output.trim()
}
addLast(value) {
let newNode = new Node(value)
// If the list is empty,
// point `head` to the newly-added node
// and exit.
if (this.head === null) {
this.head = newNode
return
}
// If the list isn’t empty,
// traverse the list by going to each node’s
// `next` node until there isn’t a `next` node...
let currentNode = this.head
while (currentNode.next) {
currentNode = currentNode.next
}
// If you’re here, `currentNode` is
// the last node in the list.
// Point `currentNode` at
// the newly-added node.
currentNode.next = newNode
}
getCount() {
let count = 0
let currentNode = this.head
// Traverse the list, keeping count of
// the nodes that you visit,
// until you’ve gone past the last node.
while (currentNode) {
currentNode = currentNode.next
count++
}
return count
}
getElementAt(index) {
let currentIndex = 0
let currentNode = this.head
// Traverse the list, keeping count of
// the nodes that you visit,
// until you’ve reached the specified node.
while (currentNode) {
if (currentIndex === index) {
// We’re at the node at the given index!
return currentNode.data
}
// We’re not there yet...
currentNode = currentNode.next
currentIndex++
}
// If you’re here, the given index is larger
// than the number of elements in the list.
return null
}
setElementAt(index, value) {
let currentIndex = 0
let currentNode = this.head
// Traverse the list, keeping count of
// the nodes that you visit,
// until you’ve reached the specified node.
while (currentNode) {
if (currentIndex === index) {
// We’re at the node at the given index!
currentNode.data = value
return true
}
// We’re not there yet...
currentNode = currentNode.next
currentIndex++
}
// If you’re here, the given index is larger
// than the number of elements in the list.
return false
}
addFirst(value) {
let newNode = new Node(value)
// If the list is empty,
// point `head` to the newly-added node
// and exit.
if (this.head === null) {
this.head = newNode
return
}
// If the list isn’t empty,
// make the current first node the second node
// and make the new node the first node.
newNode = this.head
this.head = newNode
}
insertElementAt(index, value) {
let newNode = new Node(value)
let currentIndex = 0
let currentNode = this.head
// Traverse the list, keeping count of
// the nodes that you visit,
// until you’ve reached the specified node.
while (currentNode) {
if (currentIndex === index - 1) {
// We’re at the node before the insertion point!
// Make the new node point to the next node
// and the current node point to the new node.
newNode.next = currentNode.next
currentNode.next = newNode
return true
}
// We’re not there yet...
currentNode = currentNode.next
currentIndex++
}
// If you’re here, the given index is larger
// than the number of elements in the list.
return false
}
deleteElementAt(index) {
let currentIndex = 0
let currentNode = this.head
// Traverse the list, keeping count of
// the nodes that you visit,
// until you’ve reached the specified node.
while (currentNode) {
if (currentIndex === index - 1) {
// We’re at the node before the node to be deleted!
// Make the current node point to the next node’s next node
// and set the next node’s `data` and `next` properties
// to `null`.
const deleteNode = currentNode.next
currentNode.next = deleteNode.next
deleteNode.data = null
deleteNode.next = null
return true
}
// We’re not there yet...
currentNode = currentNode.next
currentIndex++
}
// If you’re here, the given index is larger
// than the number of elements in the list.
return false
}
}
Coming up next
It’s time to reverse that list!
Previously in this series
- How to solve coding interview questions: Linked lists, part 2
- How to solve coding interview questions: Linked lists, part 1
- How to solve coding interview questions: Finding the first NON-recurring character in a string in Swift
- How to solve coding interview questions: Looking deeper into finding the first NON-recurring character in a string
- How to solve coding interview questions: The first NON-recurring character in a string
- Coding interview questions: “First recurring character” in Swift
- How to solve coding interview questions: The first recurring character in a string
- I Has the Dumb (or: How I Embarrassed Myself in My Interview with Google) — from way back in 2013
First the advice, then the backstory

Unlike those recipe sites where you have to scroll past lots of backstory and unrelated personal trivia before you get to the actual recipe, I’m going to give you the advice first.
It’s just this: in a hackathon, simple and working beats complex and non-functional.
The demo you build should be all about showing your main idea in action. The user should be able to go to your site or launch the application, use it to perform the intended task or achieve the intended result, and there should be a clear sign that the user succeeded at the end. That’s it. Anything else is gold-plating, and you don’t have time for that in a hackathon, whether you’re allotted an afternoon or, as in the case of StartupBus, three days. On a bus. With lots of interruptions.
Once again, I repeat my best hackathon advice: simple and working beats complex and non-functional.

Want to join StartupBus Florida?
It’s not too late to register to register for StartupBus Florida, which departs Tampa on the morning of Wednesday, July 27 and arrives in Austin, Texas on Friday, July 29 with surprises aplenty in between.
While on the road for three days, you’ll build a startup and its supporting application. Then on Saturday, July 30 and Sunday, July 31 in Austin, you’ll present your startup and application to judges in the semifinals (Saturday) and finals (Sunday).
Need more details? Email me to find out more!
Want to register? Go to StartupBus.com’s Apply page, select Florida, and use the invite code JOEY22.

And now, the backstory…
Here’s a story from a hackathon where I applied this principle and impressed the judges enough for them to make up a new prize category on the spot.

In 2017, GM (yes, the auto manufacturer) held “Makers Hustle Harder” hackathons in a handful of cities to see what people could build on their Next Generation Infotainment (NGI) SDK for in-car console systems.
They held one of these hackathons in Tampa at Tampa Hackerspace. and I offered to help Chris Woodard work on his app idea. I did that for most of the day, and with a couple of hours left, I came up with a goofy idea that I could whip up in very little time.
A little technical background
The NGI SDK made it possible for developers to write apps for the in-car infotainment consoles located in many GM vehicle center dashboards, like the one pictured above. The SDK gives you access to:
- An 800-pixel high by 390-pixel wide touchscreen to receive input from and display information to the user
- The voice system to respond to user commands and provide spoken responses to the user
- Data from nearly 400 sensors ranging from the state of controls (buttons and the big dial) to instrumentation (such as speed, trip odometer, orientation) to car status information (Are there passengers in the car? Are the windows open or closed?) and more.
- The navigation system to get and set navigation directions
- The media system to play or stream audio files
- The file system to create, edit, and delete files on the system
- An inter-app communication system so that apps can send messages to each other
With the SDK, developers could build and test apps for GM cars on your their own computers. It came with an emulator that lets you see your apps as they would appear on the car’s display, simulate sensor readings, and debug your app with a specialized console.
The hackathon

I arrived at Tampa Hackerspace that morning, and it was already abuzz with activity:

Outside in the parking lot were 3 NGI-equipped GM vehicles provided by Crown, a local auto dealer. Two of them were Buick Lacrosse sedans…

…and one was a GM Sierra truck:

The NGI team were there to answer our questions and help us install our apps onto the in-car console to give them some non-emulator, on-the-real-thing testing.
I performed a “smoke test” on my test app, Shotgun (an app that takes a list of names and randomly decides which one gets to “ride shotgun”) early in the morning on the Sierra’s console…

…and I have to say that there’s nothing like the feeling when your code runs for the first time on a completely new-to-you platform.
My main reason for being there was to help out Chris Woodard (whom I knew from his Cocoa / iOS programming Meetup group) on WeatherEye, his app that provides live weather reports for your planned route as you drove. When we completed it early in the afternoon, I ran a smoke test on it, and it worked as well.
With a couple of hours of “hacking time” left, I came up with a silly idea and coded it up: a timer for the game classically known as the “Chinese Fire Drill”. Here’s how it worked:
- Four people get in the car, close the doors, and someone starts the app. They’ll see this screen:

- When everyone’s ready, someone in the front presses the start button.
- If any of the doors are open when the start button is pressed, the players will be told to close all the doors first:

- If all the doors are closed when the start button is pressed, the game begins. The screen looks like this:

- Players exit the car, run around it once, return to their original seat, and close their doors.
- The game ends when all four doors are closed, at which point the time it took them to complete the drill is displayed:

(If you’d like to see the code, I’ve put it in a repo on my GitHub account.)
The app wasn’t pretty, but that’s not what hackathons are about — they’re about getting your idea to work in the time allotted. Remember: simple and working beats complex and non-functional.
I found an available test vehicle, three other people to playtest the game with me, and two camera operators to record video of a test runs. We played the game twice, and we were giggling all the time. Fitness Fire Drill (I decided to not call it Chinese Fire Drill, as the term comes from an era when “Chinese” was used as a pejorative adjective to mean sloppy, sub-par, or amateurish) was a success!
Everyone who built a project presented it at the end of the day to the panel of judges, and the organizers saved Fitness Fire Drill for the very end — it got a lot of laughs.
In the end…
My wife Anitra was flying out early the following morning on business, so rather than stay for the hackathon dinner and judges’ results, I high-tailed it home to have dinner with her. Before going to bed, I noticed that Chris had sent me an email telling me that Fitness Fire Drill won the “Judges’ Fetish” prize (a category they’d made up just for my submission), something I wasn’t expecting!
From that outcome, I learned what I now call the First Rule of Hackathons: simple and working beats complex and non-functional.

In case you missed part 1…
Before you continue reading, be sure to check out part 1! It’s where I explain what a linked list is, and provide a couple of basic classes that we’ll build on in this article.
A quick recap
A linked list is a data structure that holds data as a list of items in a specific order. Each item in the list is represented by a node, which “knows” two things:
- Its data
- Where the next node is
Here’s a picture of a node’s structure:
Linked lists are created by connecting nodes together, as shown in the diagram below for a list containing the characters a, b, c, and d in that order:
The diagram above features the following:
- Four nodes, each one for a letter in the list.
- A variable called
head, which is a pointer or reference to the first item in the list. It’s the entry point to the list, and it’s a necessary part of the list — you can’t access a linked list if you can’t access its head. - An optional variable called
tail, which is a pointer or reference to the last item in the list. It’s not absolutely necessary, but it’s convenient if you use the list like a queue, where the last element in the list is also the last item that was added to the list.
The JavaScript version of the previous article’s code
In the previous article, I provided code for the Node and LinkedList classes in Python. As promised, here are those classes implemented in JavaScript.
// JavaScript
class Node {
constructor(data) {
this.data = data
this.next = null
}
toString() {
return this.data.toString()
}
}
class LinkedList {
constructor() {
this.head = null
}
toString() {
let output = ""
let currentNode = this.head
while (currentNode) {
output += `${currentNode.data.toString()}\n`
currentNode = currentNode.next
}
toString() {
if (!this.head) {
return('Empty list.')
}
let output = ""
let currentNode = this.head
while (currentNode) {
output += `${currentNode.data.toString()}\n`
currentNode = currentNode.next
}
return output.trim()
}
addLast(data) {
let newNode = new Node(data)
// If the list is empty,
// point `head` to the newly-added node
// and exit.
if (this.head === null) {
this.head = newNode
return
}
// If the list isn’t empty,
// traverse the list by going to each node’s
// `next` node until there isn’t a `next` node...
let currentNode = this.head
while (currentNode.next) {
currentNode = currentNode.next
}
// If you’re here, `currentNode` is
// the last node in the list.
// Point `currentNode` at
// the newly-added node.
currentNode.next = newNode
}
}
…where each item in a list is represented by the node. A node knows only about the data it contains and where the next node in the list is.
The JavaScript version of Node and LinkedList uses the same algorithms as the Python version. The Python version follows the snake_case naming convention, while the JavaScript version follows the camelCase convention.
The JavaScript LinkedList class has the following members:
head: A property containing a pointer or reference to the first item in the list, ornullif the list is empty. This property has the same name in the Python version.constructor(): The class constructor, which initializesheadtonull, meaning that any newly createdLinkedListinstance is an empty list. In the Python version, the__init__()method has this role.toString(): Returns a string representation of the contents of the linked list for debugging purposes. If the list contains at least one item, it returns the contents of the list. If the list is empty, it returns the stringEmpty list. In the Python version, the__str__()method has this role.addLast(): Given a value, it creates a newNodecontaining that value and adds thatNodeto the end of the list. In the Python version, theadd_last()method has this role.
Adding more functionality to the list
In this article, we’re going to add some much-needed additional functionality to the LinkedList class, namely:
- Reporting how many elements are in the list
- Getting the value of the nth item in the list
- Setting the value of the nth item in the list
I’ll provide both Python and JavaScript implementations.
How many elements are in the list?
To find out how many elements are in a linked list, you have to start at its head and “step through” every item in the list by following each node’s next property, keeping a count of each node you visit. When you reach the last node — the one whose next property is set to None in Python or null in JavaScript — report the number of nodes you counted.
The Python version uses one of its built-in “dunder” (Pythonese for double-underscore) methods, __len__(), to report the number of items in the list. Defining __len__() for LinkedList means that any LinkedList instance will report the number of items it contains when passed as an argument to the built-in len() function. For example, if a LinkedList instance named my_list contains 5 items, len(my_list) returns the value 5.
Here’s the Python version, which you should add to the Python version of LinkedList:
# Python
def __len__(self):
count = 0
current_node = self.head
# Traverse the list, keeping count of
# the nodes that you visit,
# until you’ve gone past the last node.
while current_node:
current_node = current_node.next
count += 1
return count
The JavaScript version is getCount(). If a LinkedList instance named myList contains 5 items, len(myList) returns the value 5.
Here’s the JavaScript version, which you should add to the JavaScript version of LinkedList:
// JavaScript
getCount() {
let count = 0
let currentNode = this.head
// Traverse the list, keeping count of
// the nodes that you visit,
// until you’ve gone past the last node.
while (currentNode) {
currentNode = currentNode.next
count++
}
return count
}
How do I get the data at the nth node in the list?
To get the data at the nth node of the list, you can use an approach that’s similar to the one for counting the list’s elements. You have to start at the head and “step through” every item in the list by following each node’s next property, keeping a count of each node you visit and comparing it against n, where n is the index of the node whose data you want. When the count of nodes you’ve visited is equal to n, report the data contained within the current node.
Here’s the Python version, get_element_at(), which you should add to the Python version of LinkedList:
# Python
def get_element_at(self, index):
current_index = 0
current_node = self.head
# Traverse the list, keeping count of
# the nodes that you visit,
# until you’ve reached the specified node.
while current_node:
if current_index == index:
# We’re at the node at the given index!
return current_node.data
# We’re not there yet...
current_node = current_node.next
current_index += 1
# If you’re here, the given index is larger
# than the number of elements in the list.
return None
Here’s the JavaScript version, getElementAt(), which you should add to the JavaScript version of LinkedList:
// JavaScript
getElementAt(index) {
let currentIndex = 0
let currentNode = this.head
// Traverse the list, keeping count of
// the nodes that you visit,
// until you’ve reached the specified node.
while (currentNode) {
if (currentIndex === index) {
// We’re at the node at the given index!
return currentNode.data
}
// We’re not there yet...
currentNode = currentNode.next
currentIndex++
}
// If you’re here, the given index is larger
// than the number of elements in the list.
return null
}
How do I set the value of the nth node in the list?
To set the data at the nth node of the list, you can use an approach that’s similar to the one for getting the data at the nth node. You have to start at the head and “step through” every item in the list by following each node’s next property, keeping a count of each node you visit and comparing it against n, where n is the index of the node whose data you want. When the count of nodes you’ve visited is equal to n, set the current node’s data property to the new value.
Here’s the Python version, set_element_at(), which you should add to the Python version of LinkedList:
# Python
def set_element_at(self, index, value):
current_index = 0
current_node = self.head
# Traverse the list, keeping count of
# the nodes that you visit,
# until you’ve reached the specified node.
while current_node:
if current_index == index:
# We’re at the node at the given index!
current_node.data = value
return True
# We’re not there yet...
current_node = current_node.next
current_index += 1
# If you’re here, the given index is larger
# than the number of elements in the list.
return False
Here’s the JavaScript version, setElementAt(), which you should add to the JavaScript version of LinkedList:
// JavaScript
setElementAt(index, value) {
let currentIndex = 0
let currentNode = this.head
// Traverse the list, keeping count of
// the nodes that you visit,
// until you’ve reached the specified node.
while (currentNode) {
if (currentIndex === index) {
// We’re at the node at the given index!
currentNode.data = value
return true
}
// We’re not there yet...
currentNode = currentNode.next
currentIndex++
}
// If you’re here, the given index is larger
// than the number of elements in the list.
return false
}
The classes so far
Let’s take a look at the complete Node and LinkedList classes so far, in both Python and JavaScript.
Python
# Python
class Node:
def __init__(self, data):
self.data = data
self.next = None
def __str__(self):
return f"{self.data}"
class LinkedList:
def __init__(self):
self.head = None
def __str__(self):
if self.head is None:
return('Empty list.')
result = ""
current_node = self.head
while current_node:
result += f'{current_node}\n'
current_node = current_node.next
return result.strip()
def add_last(self, value):
new_node = Node(value)
# If the list is empty,
# point `head` to the newly-added node
# and exit.
if self.head is None:
self.head = new_node
return
# If the list isn’t empty,
# traverse the list by going to each node’s
# `next` node until there isn’t a `next` node...
current_node = self.head
while current_node.next:
current_node = current_node.next
# If you’re here, `current_node` is
# the last node in the list.
# Point `current_node` at
# the newly-added node.
current_node.next = new_node
def __len__(self):
count = 0
current_node = self.head
# Traverse the list, keeping count of
# the nodes that you visit,
# until you’ve gone past the last node.
while current_node:
current_node = current_node.next
count += 1
return count
def get_element_at(self, index):
current_index = 0
current_node = self.head
# Traverse the list, keeping count of
# the nodes that you visit,
# until you’ve reached the specified node.
while current_node:
if current_index == index:
# We’re at the node at the given index!
return current_node.data
# We’re not there yet...
current_node = current_node.next
current_index += 1
# If you’re here, the given index is larger
# than the number of elements in the list.
return None
def set_element_at(self, index, value):
current_index = 0
current_node = self.head
# Traverse the list, keeping count of
# the nodes that you visit,
# until you’ve reached the specified node.
while current_node:
if current_index == index:
# We’re at the node at the given index!
current_node.data = value
return True
# We’re not there yet...
current_node = current_node.next
current_index += 1
# If you’re here, the given index is larger
# than the number of elements in the list.
return False
JavaScript
// JavaScript
class Node {
constructor(data) {
this.data = data
this.next = null
}
toString() {
return this.data.toString()
}
}
class LinkedList {
constructor() {
this.head = null
}
toString() {
if (!this.head) {
return('Empty list.')
}
let output = ""
let currentNode = this.head
while (currentNode) {
output += `${currentNode.data.toString()}\n`
currentNode = currentNode.next
}
return output.trim()
}
addLast(value) {
let newNode = new Node(value)
// If the list is empty,
// point `head` to the newly-added node
// and exit.
if (this.head === null) {
this.head = newNode
return
}
// If the list isn’t empty,
// traverse the list by going to each node’s
// `next` node until there isn’t a `next` node...
let currentNode = this.head
while (currentNode.next) {
currentNode = currentNode.next
}
// If you’re here, `currentNode` is
// the last node in the list.
// Point `currentNode` at
// the newly-added node.
currentNode.next = newNode
}
getCount() {
let count = 0
let currentNode = this.head
// Traverse the list, keeping count of
// the nodes that you visit,
// until you’ve gone past the last node.
while (currentNode) {
currentNode = currentNode.next
count++
}
return count
}
getElementAt(index) {
let currentIndex = 0
let currentNode = this.head
// Traverse the list, keeping count of
// the nodes that you visit,
// until you’ve reached the specified node.
while (currentNode) {
if (currentIndex === index) {
// We’re at the node at the given index!
return currentNode.data
}
// We’re not there yet...
currentNode = currentNode.next
currentIndex++
}
// If you’re here, the given index is larger
// than the number of elements in the list.
return null
}
setElementAt(index, value) {
let currentIndex = 0
let currentNode = this.head
// Traverse the list, keeping count of
// the nodes that you visit,
// until you’ve reached the specified node.
while (currentNode) {
if (currentIndex === index) {
// We’re at the node at the given index!
currentNode.data = value
return true
}
// We’re not there yet...
currentNode = currentNode.next
currentIndex++
}
// If you’re here, the given index is larger
// than the number of elements in the list.
return false
}
}
Wait…this “linked list” thing is beginning to look like a Python or JavaScript array, but not as fully-featured. What’s going on here?
The truth about linked lists
Here’s the truth: there’s a better-than-even chance that you’ll never use them…directly.
If you program in most languages from the 1990s or later (for example, Python was first released in 1991, PHP’s from 1994, Java and JavaScript came out in 1995), you’re working with arrays — or in Python’s case, lists, which are almost the same thing — that you can you can add elements to, remove elements from, perform searches on, and do all sorts of things with.
When you use one of these data types in a modern language…
- Python lists or a JavaScript arrays
- Dictionaries, also known as objects in JavaScript, hashes in Ruby, or associative arrays
- Stacks and queues
- React components
…there’s a linked list behind the scenes, moving data around by traversing, adding, and deleting nodes. There’s a pretty good chance that you’re indirectly using linked lists in your day-to-day programming; you’re just insulated from the details by layers of abstractions.
So why do they still pose linked list challenges in coding interviews?

History plays a major factor.
In older languages like FORTRAN (1957), Pascal (1970), and C (1972), arrays weren’t dynamic, but fixed in size. If you declared an array with 20 elements, it remained a 20-element array. You couldn’t add or remove elements at run-time.
But Pascal and C supported pointers from the beginning, and pointers make it possible to create dynamic data structures — the kind where you can add or delete elements at run-time. In those early pre-web days, when programming languages’ standard libraries weren’t as rich and complete as today’s, and you often had to “roll your own” dynamic data structures, such as trees, queues, stacks, and…linked lists.
If you majored in computer science in the ’70s, ’80s, and even the ’90s, you were expected to know how to build your own dynamic data structures from scratch, and they most definitely appeared on the exam. These computer science majors ended up in charge at tech companies, and they expected the people they hired to know this stuff as well. Over time, it became tradition, and to this day, you’ll still get the occasional linked list question in a coding interview.
What’s the point in learning about linked lists when we’re mostly insulated from having to work with them directly?
For starters, there’s just plain old pragmatism. As long as they’re still asking linked list questions in coding interviews, it’s a good idea to get comfortable with them and be prepared to answer all manner of questions about algorithms and data structures.
Secondly, it’s a good way to get better at the kind of problem solving that we need in day-to-day programming. Working with linked lists requires us to think about pointers/references, space and time efficiency, tradeoffs, and even writing readable, maintainable code. And of course, there’s always a chance that you might have to implement a linked list yourself, whether because you’re working on an IoT or embedded programming project with a low-level language like C or implementing something lower-level such as the reconciler in React.
Coming up next
- Adding a new element to the head of a linked list
- Adding a new element at a specific place in the middle of a linked list
- Deleting a specified element of a linked list
Previously in this series
- How to solve coding interview questions: Linked lists, part 1
- How to solve coding interview questions: Finding the first NON-recurring character in a string in Swift
- How to solve coding interview questions: Looking deeper into finding the first NON-recurring character in a string
- How to solve coding interview questions: The first NON-recurring character in a string
- Coding interview questions: “First recurring character” in Swift
- How to solve coding interview questions: The first recurring character in a string
- I Has the Dumb (or: How I Embarrassed Myself in My Interview with Google) — from way back in 2013

But they’re close!
If you’re interviewing for a position that requires you to code, the odds are pretty good that you’ll have to face a coding interview. This series of articles is here to help you gain the necessary knowledge and skills to tackle them!
Over the next couple of articles in this series, I’ll walk you through a classic computer science staple: linked lists. And by the end of these articles, you’ll be able to handle this most clichéd of coding interview problems, satirized in the meme below:

You’ve probably seen the ads for AlgoExpert with the woman pictured above, where she asks you if you want a job at Google and if you know how to reverse a linked list.
But before you learn about reversing linked lists — or doing anything else with them — let’s first answer an important question: what are they?
What are linked lists?
A linked list is a data structure that holds data as a list of items in a specific order. Linked lists are simple and flexible, which is why they’re the basis of many of the data structures that you’ll probably use in your day-to-day programming.
Linked list basics
Nodes
The basic component of a linked list is a node, which is diagrammed below:
In its simplest form, a node is a data structure that holds two pieces of information:
data: This holds the actual data of the list item. For example, if the linked list is a to-do list, the data could be a string representing a task, such as “clean the bathroom.”next: A linked list is simply a set of nodes that are linked together. In addition to the data it holds, a node should also know where the next node is, and that’s what itsnextproperty is for: it points to the next item in the list. In languages like C and Go, this would be a pointer, while in languages like C#, Java, JavaScript, Kotlin, Python, and Swift, this would be a reference.
Here’s a Python implementation of a node. We’ll use it to implement a linked list:
# Python
class Node:
def __init__(self, data):
self.data = data
self.next = None
def __str__(self):
return f"{self.data}"
With Node defined, you can create a new node containing the data “Hello, world!” with this line of code:
new_node = Node("Hello, world!")
To print the data contained inside a node, call Node’s print() method, which in turn uses the value returned by its __str__() method:
print(new_node)
# Outputs “Hello, world!”
Assembling nodes into a linked list
You create a linked list by connecting nodes together using their next properties. For example, the linked list in the diagram below represents a list of the first four letters of the alphabet: a, b, c, and d, in that order:
The diagram above features the following:
- Four nodes, each one for a letter in the list.
- A variable called
head, which is a pointer or reference to the first item in the list. It’s the entry point to the list, and it’s a necessary part of the list — you can’t access a linked list if you can’t access its head. - An optional variable called
tail, which is a pointer or reference to the last item in the list. It’s not absolutely necessary, but it’s convenient if you use the list like a queue, where the last element in the list is also the last item that was added to the list.
Let’s build the linked list pictured above by putting some nodes together:
# Python
# Let’s build this linked list:
# a -> b -> c -> d
head = Node("a")
head.next = Node("b")
head.next.next = Node("c")
head.next.next.next = Node("d")
That’s a lot of nexts. Don’t worry; we’ll come up with a better way of adding items to a linked list soon.
Here’s an implementation that creates the same list but doesn’t rely on chaining nexts:
# Python
# Another way to build this linked list:
# a -> b -> c -> d
head = Node("a")
node_b = Node("b")
head.next = node_b
node_c = Node("c")
node_b.next = node_c
node_d = Node("d")
node_c.next = node_d
To see the contents of the list, you traverse it by visiting each node. This is possible because each node points to the next one in the list:
# Python
print(head)
print(head.next)
print(head.next.next)
print(head.next.next.next)
print(head.next.next.next.next)
Here’s the output for the code above:
a
b
c
d
None
Of course, the code above becomes impractical if you don’t know how many items are in the list or as the list grows in size.
Fortunately, the repetition in the code — all those prints and nexts — suggests that we can use a loop to get the same result:
# Python
current = head
while current is not None:
print(current)
current = current.next
Here’s the output for the code above:
a
b
c
d
A linked list class
Working only with nodes is a little cumbersome. Let’s put together a linked list class that makes use of the Node class:
# Python
class LinkedList:
def __init__(self):
self.head = None
def __str__(self):
if self.head is None:
return('Empty list.')
result = ""
current_node = self.head
while current_node is not None:
result += f'{current_node}\n'
current_node = current_node.next
return result.strip()
def add_last(self, data):
new_node = Node(data)
# If the list is empty,
# point `head` to the newly-added node
# and exit.
if self.head is None:
self.head = new_node
return
# If the list isn’t empty,
# traverse the list by going to each node’s
# `next` node until there isn’t a `next` node...
current_node = self.head
while current_node.next:
current_node = current_node.next
# If you’re here, `current_node` is
# the last node in the list.
# Point `current_node` at
# the newly-added node.
current_node.next = new_node
This LinkedList class has the following members:
head: A property containing a pointer or reference to the first item in the list, orNoneif the list is empty.__init__(): The class initializer, which initializesheadtoNone, meaning that any newly createdLinkedListinstance is an empty list.__str__(): Returns a string representation of the contents of the linked list for debugging purposes. If the list contains at least one item, it returns the contents of the list. If the list is empty, it returns the stringEmpty list.add_last(): Given a value, it creates a newNodecontaining that value and adds thatNodeto the end of the list.
With this class defined, building a new list requires considerably less typing…
# Python
list = LinkedList()
list.add_last("a")
list.add_last("b")
list.add_last("c")
list.add_last("d")
…and displaying its contents is reduced to a single function call, print(list), which produces this output:
a
b
c
d
Coming up next:
- JavaScript implementations
- Adding an item to the start of a linked list
- Finding an item in a linked list
- Will you ever use a linked list, and why do they ask linked list questions in coding interviews?
Previously in this series
- How to solve coding interview questions: Finding the first NON-recurring character in a string in Swift
- How to solve coding interview questions: Looking deeper into finding the first NON-recurring character in a string
- How to solve coding interview questions: The first NON-recurring character in a string
- Coding interview questions: “First recurring character” in Swift
- How to solve coding interview questions: The first recurring character in a string
- I Has the Dumb (or: How I Embarrassed Myself in My Interview with Google) — from way back in 2013

In previous posts, I’ve presented Python, JavaScript, and TypeScript solutions for the coding interview challenge: “Write a function that returns the first NON-recurring character in a given string.” In this post, I’ll show you my solution in Swift.
Here’s a table that provides some sample input and corresponding expected output for this function:
| If you give the function this input… | …it should produce this output: |
aabbbXccdd | X |
a🤣abbbXcc3dd | 🤣 |
aabbccdd | null / None / nil |
The algorithm
I’ve been using an algorithm that takes on the problem in two stages:
In the first stage, the function steps through the input string one character at a time, counting the number of times each character in the string appears in a “character record”. Because we’re looking for the first non-recurring character in the input string, the order in which data is stored in the character record is important. It needs to maintain insertion order — that is, the order of the character record must be the same order in which each unique character in the input string first appears.
For example, given the input string aabbbXccdd, the function should build a character record that looks like this:
| Character | Count |
a | 2 |
b | 3 |
X | 1 |
c | 2 |
d | 2 |
Given the input string a🤣abbbXcc3dd, it should build a character record that looks like this:
| Character | Count |
a | 2 |
🤣 | 1 |
b | 3 |
X | 1 |
c | 2 |
3 | 1 |
d | 2 |
Given the input string aab, it should build a character record that looks like this:bccdd
| Character | Count |
a | 2 |
b | 2 |
c | 2 |
d | 2 |
Once the function has built the character record, it’s time to move to the second stage, where it iterates through the character record in search of a character with a count of 1, and:
- If the function finds such a character, it exits the function at the first such occurrence, returning that character. For the input string
aabbbXccdd, it returnsX, and for the input stringa🤣abbbXcc3dd, it returns🤣. - If the function doesn’t find any characters with a count of 1, it exits the function, having gone through every character in the character record, returning a null value (which in the case of Swift is
nil).
Using a Swift OrderedDictionary
The character record is the key to making the algorithm work, and the key to the character record is that must be an ordered collection. If I add a, b, and c to the character record, it must maintain the order a, b, c.
This isn’t a problem in Python. While Python dictionaries have traditionally been unordered, as of Python 3.7, dictionaries maintain insertion order. In the previous articles covering this coding interview question, my Python solutions used a regular Python dictionary.
Because JavaScript runs in so many places in so many versions, I decided not to trust that everyone would be running a later version, which preserves insertion order. In the previous article, I wrote a JavaScript solution that implemented the character record using Map, a key-value data structure that keeps the items stored in the order in which they were inserted.
Swift’s built-in Dictionary does not keep the items in any defined order. Luckily, the Swift Collections package provides OrderedDictionary, which gives us both key-value storage and insertion order.
You’ll need to add Swift Collections to your project in order to use it. To do this, select File → Add Packages…
The dialog box for adding packages will appear:

Do the following:
- Enter swift-collections into the search field.
- Select swift-collections from the package list.
- Click Add Package.
You’ll be presented with a list of products within the Swift Collections package:

For this exercise, you’ll need only OrderedCollections, so check its box and click Add Package, which will add the package to your project.
Implementing the solution
Now we can implement the solution!
// We need this for `OrderedDictionary`
import OrderedCollections
func firstNonRecurringCharacter(text: String) -> String? {
var characterRecord = OrderedDictionary<Character, Int>()
for character in text {
if characterRecord.keys.contains(character) {
characterRecord[character]! += 1
} else {
characterRecord[character] = 1
}
}
for character in characterRecord.keys {
if characterRecord[character] == 1 {
return String(character)
}
}
return nil
}
characterRecord, which keeps track of the characters encountered as we go character by character through the input string, is an OrderedDictionary. Note that with Swift, which is both statically and strongly typed, we need to specify that characterRecord’s keys are of type Character and its values are Ints.
After that, the implementation’s similar to my Python and JavaScript versions.
Previously in this series
- How to solve coding interview questions: Looking deeper into finding the first NON-recurring character in a string
- How to solve coding interview questions: The first NON-recurring character in a string
- Coding interview questions: “First recurring character” in Swift
- How to solve coding interview questions: The first recurring character in a string
- I Has the Dumb (or: How I Embarrassed Myself in My Interview with Google) — from way back in 2013









